|
Author
|
Topic: The Ultimate SDOE Update
|
Spoonman Pilot
|
posted 04-01- 05:39 PM
For some time now there has been a lot of talk about developing an online standard for Fighter Squadron. With the recent rash of new aircraft, terrain, and ground objects, we are at a crossroads for trying to establish a on-line standard for everyone to use.What I am proposing to do will require some approval, but I'm sure that will not be a problem, but here it is: I will on my one time, gather EVERY submission made for SDOE. From Peter Hawks Flying Zepplin to the Flying V, from the WWI Fokker to the WWII Bf-109F, I will collect everything and package it together into one HUGE addon. Winter terrain, WWI terrain, every WWI aircraft and object, every WWII aircraft and ground objects (including the Carriers), and as well Meatwaters sound pack I will throw it into one large Zipfile (50+ Megs). PLUS - for those of you who have a slow online connection, I will burn you a CD as long as you pay for the cost of shipping and the CD. I will give you a way to order them. Now, I have to work out this point with the boss, but I really don't see any hickups. What I need Every aircraft, every object, either in file or the URL for download - I need it all. Once I have everything (I'll set a deadline for submission), I will package everything together and make it available for download. Now, I leave this in your lap for you all to ponder and consider. If you want this done, I need your support! I will make the final decision by Friday (April 6th) on the CD thing, but it also depends on the communities interest whether or not we need this done. I feel we do before it gets out of hand. If you wish to discuss or help out with the project, please email me here: brandor@home.com . Cheers. Ed "Spoonman" Reddy SDOE Fanatic IP: Logged |
Condor Pilot
|
posted 04-01- 06:25 PM
Sounds great!!!!!!Have you checked www.fshanger.com/files/ Most everything (I would say about 95%) is there now avaible for download. Just a thought but it might be easier to let it all stay as a download. (A lot less work for you I am sure). Condor out ------------------
IP: Logged |
Zoycite JAG
|
posted 04-01- 06:35 PM
Spoonman,You have done a great service to us in your efforts to help promote this sim to the general public. I have no problem with you releasing my stuff as part of your proposed package. I looked at the link below and it didnt work. If my stuff is available elsewhere its news to me. BTW thanks for asking guys  I will mail you the links ot the direct zips of the FokkerDVII and Rhineland Winter. Also dont forget the Nations projects. My only question to you is this. Will you be able to keep the files updated? Atleast current with the release of future plane packs. Good luck.
------------------ Zoycite 33rd~GS visit The War Paint Factory IP: Logged |
Commando Pilot
|
posted 04-01- 06:35 PM
I'd go for the CD and still do the download as well, great for those HD diaster recoveries which we all dread and also which happen more than you would think. Could you put both the Par files and the unbig'd versions on the CD ? Think its a great Idea. IP: Logged |
Jerry Pilot
|
posted 04-01- 07:01 PM
Sounds great, especially the CD part. I do hope someone will then tell us what we can "delete" from our FS folders after installing it. This holds true for any par files created too. As long as we have the original folders from the original installations they will over ride the par data...I think.IP: Logged |
Nat Pilot
|
posted 04-01- 07:21 PM
I'm glad to see all this, to be honest the way the board has been all I seem to do is sigh at it recently... I'd be more than glad to supply you with the link to the Snowy Dover terrain if you're adding extra terrains aswell, at the moment it comes in 3 parts due to upload restrictions on xoom, but once the bat file is run you will have one fully working zip file.Let us know if you want terrains included, right now other than skins thats all I got to offer. Thanks SM... think this is needed right now ~Nat~
------------------ JV~44 "Naturlich" If you can't beat em.... out run em! there again, you could go buy a shiny new F4U, and kick some butt!!! <b>Nats FS-SDOE Site</b>
IP: Logged |
Raptor2 Cadet
|
posted 04-01- 09:16 PM
Dont have much time but here goes....Dont mean to be rude but i dont think this is a good idea, but it is a bright idea. If this is done, you got to make sure these files are final and not beta. If they are beta, new versions of that beta could be released causing you to overwrite old files from the 50mb zip which could cause more confusement and that doesnt look pretty. But like i said, if these files are final, all good. We certainly want to fly the latest and the geatest. i know something like this has be done, i think making seperate WWI pack and a WWII pack would be better. Smaller d/loads and more organized. Both will have to be compatible with each other of coarse. Please reply any flames and comments....  http://PlaneCentral.tripod.com ------------------ Raptor2
[This message has been edited by Raptor2 (edited 04-01-2000).] IP: Logged |
Raptor2 Cadet
|
posted 04-01- 09:30 PM
I have thought about my reply and thought that a WWI pack and WWII pack wouldnt be any better, cause both players would still need them both to make matches instead of mis-matches. I think the 50mb zip is the best thing to do but i still believe these files must be final and not beta. But is that possible since most is beta, i dont know... http://PlaneCentral.tripod.com ------------------ Raptor2
IP: Logged |
nealg Pilot
|
posted 04-01- 10:39 PM
I think it is a great plan; Spanky also posted a great idea, along the same lines, but Spoonman's idea may be advantageous in one extra respect; the CD idea. I, of course, have nothing to contribute in the way of add ons, but I can refer newbies to a central location. And if this includes extra exposure at Combatsim, with all the traffic at that site, then it adds even more weight.I'm really glad there are people here who are listening and thinking; thanks from 'just a pilot'...
------------------ nealg=FC=
IP: Logged |
Nat Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 05:57 AM
a central d/l area would be cool, I get alot of hits as I'm sure most other ppl do to their sites, but I've noticed recently I get alot of referals from other message boards etc, so I think it'd be great to have that, with all our sites main paging a link to it. But that said.. I'd pay the money for it on CD, damn right I would, that being said.... please if you are able to make the CD's.. try to use re-writeables, and format them first, then after we've bought it, it'd be an excellent place to store any future addons... god I dread the thought right now of ever having to reformat and d/l all this stuff again.. lolStill... from head to toe, I like the idea  ~Nat~ IP: Logged |
Razer Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 11:19 AM
Spoon,As it is a great idea, Me and Jaguar had this idea many months ago about giving out a CD of the Hangar. After many days of email tag we found that since planes was changing all the time that once you got the CD back something on it would be out of date. As for a central site to download the stuff is the whole reason why the hangar was created. Now there is so many sites it's hard to keep things on one page. Since most people thta have sites don't want their files on other pages. This is the reason the Hangar doesn't have everything.  ------------------
Tony "Razer" Martin http://www.fshangar.com IP: Logged |
Spoonman Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 12:11 PM
That's true Razer, but my point is that we need a starting point for all the add-ons. It was once said "It is far easier to finish building your boat once the keel had been laid down". If we get a standard, I could always release small incrimental updates for new planes. We need a starting point for all our aircraft and once that is met, it is far easier to update the standard with a 500k file than it would be with a 50000k file.  I'm talking about incorporating every single addon into a couple of PAR files so that the change is seamless. I'm going to try and post a cut-off date for submissions, and once that is done, I'll post the update in a SINGLE place for everyone to download. Over the next few weeks, I'll be contacting individuals who have released their add-ons about the current state. From there if it is final version (non-beta), I will add them into the release. Now, I need a name for this add-on. Does anyone have a suggestion for a name? Ie. Boxset 1? :/ Spoon
IP: Logged |
Commando Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 12:24 PM
My suggestion for name is SDOE 2000, then release a new one every 6 or 12 months. IP: Logged |
lfbpro Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 01:46 PM
whaouh sounds great man!espacially the CD i agree at 100% i think that a new issue every six month is a good idea too! cheers and fly high!!------------------ -=BAB=-lfbpro IP: Logged |
BULLET Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 02:00 PM
Spoonman has a great idea but if he is going to do this right he needs everybodys help. I know that there are some avid plane builders here that live for open plane, but maybe we should put a cap on releases for a while. At least till everything gets straightened out. What is the point of putting together a great release like this if 2 days later more new stuff is released and the whole cycle starts again. Maybe some release rules should be made up.
IP: Logged |
jedi Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 03:00 PM
Well, different spin on it here...I'm about 99% sure I have the current versions of the planes. I know I don't have the tundra terrain or the snowy Dover or WWI terrain yet. I'm not sure I want to download, say, 50Meg when I only need 30Meg of stuff. Would it not make sense to have a central download location, but have the individual files available? It would, of course, take twice the space to have a huge "pack" and all the separate update files as well. The advantage to having the individual files there is that, when someone DOES update a plane (and guess what, there will be new Corsairs about a week after the contest is over) you can simply replace the individual aircraft file, change the banner or readme at the site, and then folks would know that they need to download maybe one or two "new" planes as well as the mongo "FS Updater" file. Then you "repack" the big file every couple of months with the most current stuff, but leave the individual files available as well. Just a suggestion of course. I think the Huge File Idea (tm) is a good one. I would suggest that the info header at the top of the page also links to a resumable download utility such as Getright or Gozilla tho. The odds of my computer and Inet connection completing a 50Meg download unassisted are practically nil.  ------------------ --jedi-- IP: Logged |
jedi Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 03:08 PM
Oh yeah, I forgot...ANOTHER thing we should do is have a sort of "semi-official" list of the website gurus who are committing to maintain the up-to-date files. That way the designers can notify or email their new stuff to 4 or 5 guys and be pretty sure that the "main" update sites for the community have the correct stuff. It's pretty much impossible for a designer, once he posts a plane, to INSURE that the most current version is on ANY of the download sites except his own. Having some "sanctioned" sites that the designers and web site gurus all agree to keep current seems like one way to minimize online chaos, no? 
------------------ --jedi-- IP: Logged |
Spanky the Mad Dog Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 03:31 PM
Spanky here... Release rules is a great idea. freaking great idea. CD is not. things change too fast, way to fast. A 50 meg zip with EVERYTHING in it could be good, with updates every week or 3. IP: Logged |
goth Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 03:46 PM
Grand idea and plan spoonman. I like the idea a lot. For those of you worried about the Ultimate Update becoming outdated quickly, I'm sure it will, but that's no reason to hold off of creating a starting point for new additions. Right now, if you have to reload, you have to download numerous files from numeous places. If an update comes out you stil have to go get that as well. Having a central large download of "SDOE Standard as of 4/15/2000" for example would allow you to get up to date on the online standard and extras as of that date. Then you can seek out individual planes and extras to fill out your install to the most up to date options. Then, should a new standard be created, a new Ultimate Update could be created bringing everything to date as of that time. It will never be 100% up to date, but it will be a fast way to get very close, very quickly. Its more than any game I've ever bought was willing ot do. They'd make you buy a new version. Good idea Spoonman. I wholehartedly support it. IP: Logged |
Sv Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 04:45 PM
I like it, if it would act as a sort of OpenPlane archive pack! Include alpha, beta, old and new! Fun to browse!But I do not think it would help as far as an on-line standard. This seems to require allot of work and may change monthly, also the WWI pack may roll out new versions seperate from the WW2. This could, however, allow some terrain additions to become on-line standars. The winter, the night, the WWI terrain, etc. I think there is certainly value to this in terms of just collecting everything ever made. I would think it would be best to let people browe the archive/CD and install what they want to when they want to - as opposed to istalling every object, what a mess! But this is just my personal feeling. I would be happy to supply you with URLs to everything I have made... ------------------ -Sv =FC= WWI in SDOE!
IP: Logged |
Sun Tzu Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 05:51 PM
I love this ideal and am ready to place my order for the CD. Please keep us posted. Add your site here http://pub10.ezboard.com/bnoflyzone.html
------------------ Sun Tzu's Officers Club http://nosuntzu.homestead.com/index.html
IP: Logged |
weasel Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 09:31 PM
I like Sv's ideas. Put out a CD every 6 months, Make only the finished products the online standard but include the other beta planes to browse. Feedback on the planes could be given and the community could address the bugs for the next CD release. This would contribute to the online standard and allow constructive criticism to the next online standard. Count me in on ordering a CD! IP: Logged |
Spanky the Mad Dog Pilot
|
posted 04-02- 10:17 PM
Spanky here.. 6 months? you guys are insane. it will be outdated in probly 2 or 3. IP: Logged |
Jerry Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 12:06 AM
Even with the CD what's to prevent someone from posting updates to their plane or someone elses plane. And what's to prevent someone from downloading those updates? For example: if the Contest Pack were an online standard, Laika has already posted an update to it. He's proud of his I16 and wants it to be as good as possible. Are you going to tell him to stop working on it and not to post improvements? Are you going to tell me I can't download his improvements because they are not the online standard? I would like to have the CD because it insures that I have everything as of it's publishing date. But after that you still have to rely on people's self-discipline and know-how to keep non-standard items away from online IP: Logged |
ReaperMan Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 01:04 AM
The CD is a good idea, but I don't know about a download. It would be way more than 50 megs. I put all the terrains (before Atilla's terrain) into one parfile and zipped it up and it was about 50 megs. Add on everything else and I'm thinking it would round out to about 100. Then again, I know I have over 100 megs worth of SDOE stuff in my Download folder... Which is why the CD is a good idea, because let's say I had to format my HD... well I'd have to go through finding each and every file again and downloading them all over again on my dial-up connection. There would be the issue with things changing, but not everything changes and it would be a good starting point nonetheless.------------------ -=TheReaper=-
IP: Logged |
Spanky the Mad Dog Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 07:26 AM
Spanky here... Well you guys can do the cd thing. Can we just make sure that the cd files are all on a web page or FTP. I'll just DL it. That cd will be out of date way too fast. IP: Logged |
Whirlwind Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 10:02 AM
Sounds good, but wait for the next SDOE patch so you can include that as well, also wait for the contest mayhem and the minor tweakings (if any) that the contest planes will get can be included.IP: Logged |
Spoonman Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 10:23 AM
You guys are reading way too much worrying about an online standard.What I will do is do a 'monthly' update where guys can download a single file that will update the standard, include any new fixes, skins, objects, and especially - beta patches from Michael. The more I think about this, the easier it is getting.  Spoon IP: Logged |
Condor Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 11:28 AM
SpoonmanIt is nice to see you took my advice  I really do think your decision is the best way to go. Condor out ------------------
IP: Logged |
Commando Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 02:01 PM
What about charging an extra few $ for the CD and using this to cover the prize money for the next contest. Then the next CD release would be timed to contain the next Contest plane entries and again generate the prize money for the third contest and so on and on. That way we all get to give to the prize pot not a few generous individuals and the contest can be run again in the future.IP: Logged |
Spanky the Mad Dog Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 05:06 PM
Spanky here.. Its all sounds good until you check out the legal side of selling that CD. There is no way that could fly if Activision stepped in.
IP: Logged |
Spoonman Pilot
|
posted 04-03- 05:28 PM
Good point. The more I think about it, the more buggered I am trying to do it. Uh oh.  Let me do some investigating. Spoon IP: Logged |
weasel Pilot
|
posted 04-04- 07:27 PM
Spoondude, Keep the faith buddy. Let us know what you find out about the legalities. Sorry about the standards thread. How about waiting for the next plane pack to cut your first CD?
IP: Logged |
Thunder Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 08:05 AM
Great idea.. I have planned to make a CD for myself for a while now.Maybe we should limit plane and update releases to the first of every month. OK I just got shot down (again) by every plane maker but surely you can hold off until the first of the following month to release it. It might help stop the endless patches saga. Also to help stop mismatches use two copies of SDOE on your machine. One to use online using ONLY the 'ONLINE STANDARD' , and one to muck around with all the pretty new planes! Just my 5 cents worth. (2 cent coin no longer exist here in Aus)
[This message has been edited by Thunder (edited 04-05-2000).] IP: Logged |
Crankshaft Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 08:22 AM
I have done the CD bit already. I Use a re-writable one if possible, as it will be a never ending story keeping it up to date I hope. Hey Reaperman, just an idea. I have my hard drive partitioned, C,D,& E. Winblows and other essential programs are on C, all sims and games on D, and all my accumulated trivia and zip files are on E. I can format C:\ and don't have to worry about losing the rest.Clear Skies, Crank IP: Logged |
Spyder Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 10:12 AM
You should have no problems charging a 'reasonable' fee for the cd(s), as long as it's just for the media and posting, stretching the purported cost of the cd a little will be fine for contest purposes! Same principle as shareware vendors selling disks with freeware/shareware collections on them. Are we getting paranoid worrying about Activision? I doubt they would want the publicity for taking on a few simmers over a distribution such as this. ------------------ IP: Logged |
Tailslide Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 10:25 AM
IEN, the makers of Warbirds threatened to sue me just for having a link to the freehost site from my site (one of hundreds of links). A pack of wolv.. i mean lawyers is hard to reason with. If someone decides to flush a bunch of money on litigation it could make life interesting ) TS ------------------ TS Aircombat IP: Logged |
Serval_EAF322 Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 11:55 AM
I like this idea, but one small comment: For download purposes: is one BIG file not too much for download? Maybe on-line you should split it into multiple packages.....At the moment I'm working on a util that does the following: When you run it, checks the installed add-ons, looks on internet and downloads a small database (update maybe) and then checks your files with the info in the database. Then it tells you which of your files are not standard, and (if the maker or updater of the database supplies this info) gives you the download link for the update. I am a developper, but I do not have the time to maintain this database myself (in fact I now hardly have an idea what is available), so it would be nice if one of the 'leading' persons is prepared to keep an eye on the standard and puts it into the database (I try to let it be as automatic as possible where developpers can send imports to this person etc.) and sets it on-line. I'm also looking into the possability were you can check your data vs that of another player before you connect to a server.... I hope you guys will like this.... IP: Logged |
Spanky the Mad Dog Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 12:49 PM
Spanky here.... K take a look at this site http://www.3dgw.com/simfiles/
He has my idea already running in a lean sort of way. This will work out perfectly if everyone uses it. Maybe we can get something like this hosted right off the left hand menu on www.fightersquadron.com Then when you make a new plane or anything you just post a little blurb on the forum about it and tell people to look on the releases page. Everything will be there and it will always be the latest version.
[This message has been edited by Spanky the Mad Dog (edited 04-05-2000).] IP: Logged |
Serval_EAF322 Pilot
|
posted 04-05- 03:19 PM
My idea is this:No surfing to a site to check yourself if there is something new. The program tells you that there is something new (and added to the standard), and helps you installing it. IP: Logged |